Negotiate the Exit Before the Entry – Part 3

Today I listened to a very interesting, albeit brief, discussion about pre-negotiating the exit before the initial investment at the Venture Panel at the 2010 Wharton Health Care Business Conference.  The moderator asked about structured transactions where the upside is capped by way of an option with a pharma company to purchase the asset/company after a predetermined milestone.  The panelists were almost all bullish on this idea with some suggesting that they employ this with great frequency.  While I’m not surprised, I do think it has become much more acceptable than before given the continued poor exit environment.

Brenda Gavin, Partner at Quaker BioVentures, mentioned that there were only 20 M&A exits in 2009 from venture backed companies that would constitute a good return.  She mentioned that there are 3,400 biotechs, all of whom are for sale at any given point.  The exit ratio therefore isn’t so good, especially with effectively no IPOs taking place.  As such, if a VC can pre-negotiate a “4x” as she mentioned, she would take that any day over an uncertain 10x.

Steven St. Peter from MPM commented on the MPM/Novartis strategic fund as well as other non-disclosed deals of a similar option nature with other pharma companies.  He said their fund was doing these deals since 1996, but it wasn’t formalized until 2006 with Novartis.  His interesting insight is that there is a real range of exit values for biotech M&A.  Given the amount that generally needs to be invested to get there, there already is an effective cap on returns.  There might be one outlier per year but you can’t set-up your fund expecting outliers.  Given the effective cap on M&A returns, why not cap your return earlier to derisk the exit?  This makes perfect sense to me and something that was mentioned in this blog half a year ago.

Pharma companies rely on biotechs for a supply of innovative assets to fill their pipeline.  They need the VCs to make these risky investments to fund the early stage development.  More companies will be asked by their board to find a partner prior to the next round of financing both to derisk the round as well as provide validation.  This type of pre-negotiated exit arrangement I predict will become even more common going forward as VCs try to improve their returns.

Comments

[nike soccer cleats]

" You don't push me in his lie ... ..." After attending the "serie a hall of fame" awards ceremony, mizuno wave ignitus AC Milan vice-president Galliani Tevez wear puma powercat 1.10 was asked to transfer issue open such a joke. That was a joke, but gives a signal, the Rossoneri in Tevez wear adidas f50 adizero prime introduction has made breakthrough progress.

The reason is very simple, if AC Milan and there is no substantial breakthrough, Galliani wear adidas f50 adizero trx can play official say a words, that's not a lie. Mood good Milan great housekeeper with euphemistic way revealed that the Rossoneri wear adidas adipower predator are close to the fact that Tevez. But soon, the Italy media have found Galliani wear adidas predator x trx what's at the back of it.

In Florence, after receiving the award, Galliani immediately back to Milan City, and came to Milan's famous" - Jan Nino wear adidas adipure iv trx" hotel. The Lombard television reporter surprised to find and Galliani for this dinner was Tevez's agent Kia Joorabchian wear nike mercurial vapor superfly iii and transfer of middleman, Tevez 's agent in Italy agent Zhu Saipei resor. This dinner is very hurried, nike tiempo legend ii probably spent only one hour, then three people stepping into the hotel in another room. The Lombard wear nike total 90 laser iii television reporters only vaguely see three people in a piece of paper and write something, and nike ctr360 maestri ii elite signed the" calligraphy and painting, though unknown to those documents what content, but a little imagination. I can guess a pretty adidas f50 cleats close. Galliani and Kia Joorabchian is definitely not like Berlusconi in the European Parliament as painting nudes, adipower predator this document if not Tevez join AC Milan contract, will be associated with some adidas adipure iv contract.

When Galliani left" - Jan Nino" Hotel Italy reporter won't let go of Galliani wear mercurial superfly safari, Milan great housekeeper with undisguised smile replied:" this is active at night, we had mercurial superfly iii a good dinner. But I won't tell you anything ... ..." Kia Joorabchian was later accepted" Milan news "nike mercurial vapor superfly safari iii interview also reaffirmed Tevez wear nike tiempo legend iv elite joined the Milan desire:" Tevez wear nike ctr360 maestri ii elite is currently undergoing high intensity training, he hopes to become a big club in January after the protagonist.adidas adipower predator AC Milan are a great club, although there are other Italy teams in the competition. Back to Brazil? adidas f50 adizero trx Temporary Tevez just wants to stay in Europe, he also wants to become a great star."

" Slow motion" adidas f50 adizero prime that Mancheng also want 5000000 euros lease fee, which is in any case not willing to accept the rossoneri wear cheap adidas soccer cleats. No matter what kind of view, Galliani's smile is problem.</p>
Now for the AC Milan fans, Tevez wear cheap nike soccer cleats could join is not main problems, they are more concerned with the arrival of Tevez will fit in the team. The Rossoneri wear adidas soccer cleats attack the most is the lack of individual players, Ibrahimovic wear nike soccer cleats also said yesterday in an interview said:" I was the world's first star, that don't even need to use globes to prove!" Similarly mixed with Tevez can and Ibrahimovic wear soccer cleats get along well, will be in for a long time has soccer cleats buy become a hot topic of discussion.

[soccer cleats]

In Liverpool 0-1 defeat to Fulham in the battle, Suarez wear nike tiempo legend iv is very depressed, Uruguay striker wear nike mercurial vapor superfly iii was a beautiful goal by referee mistakenly blows, this makes Liverpool which lasts 6 round league tournament goal drought continues. nike total 90 laser iv In addition, in the game the Juarez continuously by the fans, provocative, and he wear nike ctr360 maestri ii elite is also very not calm the finger in response to fans.

The game although Liverpool have failed to score, but Suarez wear cheap nike soccer cleats performance or something, because the Uruguay God front almost help Liverpool scored. Enrique wear adidas f50 adizero trx left the game sixty-fifth minutes, select the biography penetrating Fulham five-person close defense, Suarez wear adidas adipower predator trx speed forward exquisite carried any attack Schwarzer, then a half turn volley into the net, the action is very clear, adidas adipure iv sl make smooth reading. If this goal effectively, so this ball is the premier best goal. But the referee didn't get the hint, hint offside flag. cheap adidas soccer cleats But replays showed, this is definitely a good shot, not offside.

After the" Daily Mail" and" mirror",adidas f50 adizero said, Suarez's goal was the strike, magistrate misjudgment killed the wonderful goals. Therefore, Suarez wear adidas adipower predator is very depressed, because such wonderful goals in his occupation career also does not see more. In addition to this opportunity, Suarez wear adidas adipure iv sl is also tax one's ingenuity to Liverpool scored, fifty-fourth minutes, the Suarez forbidden area ball had thought out wife brede Hangeland, the latter defensive Liverpool striker foul suspicion, Suarez wear nike total 90 laser iv in the restricted area for holding the ball, the referee penalty call, but a penalty to Suarez wear nike tiempo legend iv handball foul.

This fall is Suarez the performance of a microcosm of the game in Liverpool, new"mercurial vapor superfly iii recurrent" fell, this caused the craven cottage in great dissatisfaction with the fans, so the Fulham fans wear nike mercurial vapor superfly iii unsparing will hiss for Suarez. In the face of the booing fans, has been a nike mercurial vapor superfly iii bit depressed Suarez immediately, angry with the middle finger in response to Fulham fans. While this nike ctr360 maestri ii elite may as he called FA punishment, to know Suarez wear nike total 90 laser iv alleged racial discrimination case is still under investigation, he was now in the race to the finger, adidas f50 adizero trx which is obviously very irrational behavior.</p>
" Frustration. At Fulham, Liverpool in power do not score points,adidas f50 adizero prime 0-1 lose. Suarez goal offside penalty to Bo, also did not succeed, the home adidas adipure iv sl team fan boos, he refers to him. And his racial insults dispute, is still in the review process, his adidas adipower predator national team in good condition, always cannot be transformed into Liverpool's goal. The nike tiempo legend iv elite vertical finger, but also by the new punishment."